Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares

Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares |

I’m so happy to be back online with you all, and I hope you all like the new look as much as I do – we were going for fresh, bright, clean, and easy-to-use, and I’d love to hear your thoughts on whether we achieved that! Naturally, I decided the blog should go down right when my parents were in town, things were a little wonky with my pregnancy, it was Easter, and my husband was coming home after months away…smart right?  So other priorities meant it took a little longer than expected, but we’re all here, all in one piece, and there are treats, for your belly and your mailbox!  See below the recipe for what you could win and how to enter :) {Update: Giveaway closed. Congrats to Danielle and Jodi, the two winners!}

First of all, a huge shout-out to my talented designer (and beautiful sister) Chelsea, owner of Third Floor Design Studio, who put up with my endless emails of “should the menu be all-caps?” and “can the coral be a little paler and the background a little less solid?” and other such inane queries.  She deserves more than a few pans of Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares.

Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares |

What makes these chocolate chip squares so great?  Cream cheese and marshmallows.  I love the ease of squares over cookies, and chocolate chip squares are so good fresh, but they have a nasty habit of drying out too quickly.  I solved that problem in a kind of accidental way with chocolate cream cheese.  Philadelphia cream cheese recently introduced a spreadable chocolate cream cheese, so naturally I had to try it.  The grocery store had the large tub on sale for the same price as the small tub, so you can imagine which one I went home with.

Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares |

Unfortunately, it wasn’t quite as versatile as a breakfast food as I’d hoped (although it makes for a great apple dip), so I was looking for other ways to use it.  My mom’s chocolate chip square recipe calls for 2/3 cup of butter, which is so annoying, right?  Change that to a standard, simple 1/2 cup of butter, and add 1/4 cup of chocolate cream cheese (regular cream cheese works just fine too).  Problem solved, deliciously.

Then I found a bag of cocoa-coated truffles in my cupboard, which I love except for the cocoa coating which is just so not worth getting through.  Chop those up into big chunks and they are so much better than regular chocolate chips!

Sprinkle marshmallows in the dough for extra sweetness, reduce the granulated sugar so they stay chewy longer, and voilà – seriously good chocolate chip squares!  The marshmallows in the batter just melt into oblivion, so you definitely want to stick a few into the top to make ’em look pretty and give a hint at the flavours that lie within. My family devoured these in record time, and I’m sure yours will too…and don’t forget to scroll below the recipe for giveaway details!

Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares |

4.4 from 7 reviews
Marshmallow Chocolate Chip Squares
Total time
A sweet, marshmallow-studded chocolate chip square that stays chewy for days.
Recipe type: Bars & Squares
Serves: 24-32
  • ½ cup butter, softened
  • ⅓ cup spreadable chocolate cream cheese (or regular cream cheese)
  • ½ cup granulated sugar
  • 1 cup lightly packed brown sugar
  • 2 large eggs
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 2 cups all purpose flour
  • 1 teaspoon baking powder
  • ¼ teaspoon baking soda
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • 1 cup chopped milk chocolate (plus an additional ¼ cup for topping)
  • 1½ cups miniature marshmallows (plus an additional ½ cup for topping)
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit. Grease a 9x13" baking dish or spray with cooking spray.
  2. In large bowl with an electric mixer, beat butter and cream cheese briefly to combine. Add both sugars, eggs, and vanilla and beat for 3-4 minutes, until pale and very creamy.
  3. Add flour and salt to bowl and mix just to combine.
  4. Stir in chocolate chunks and marshmallows.
  5. Dump batter into prepared pan and spread it out with slightly dampened hands, pressing it as smooth as possible. Stick remaining chocolate chunks and marshmallows randomly into the dough.
  6. Bake for 22-24 minutes, until bars are just golden and juuuust set in the middle - do not overbake or they will be dry. Let cool completely before cutting into bars.
  7. Store in an airtight plastic container at room temperature for up to 5 days, or wrap well and freeze for longer storage.

GIVEAWAY!! (Runs April 28 – May 5, 2014)

To celebrate the re-launch of the freshly designed blog, and because I planned to do a giveaway when I hit 1,000 Facebook fans and that got away from me, there are now TWO chances to win! Go big or go home, am I right?

What will you win and who’s eligible?  You’ll win a personalized surprise box!  Once I’ve drawn the winner’s names, I’ll send out your special surprise package that will be delivered to your door anywhere in Canada or the United States.  I can tell you it will contain a cookbook or two, some fun kitchen accessories, some treats, and just an all-round bit of this and that.  I love getting mail, and I want to spread that love to two of you.

How to enter: There are two ways, and there will be two winners, so you can enter in both places!

First, you can enter by leaving a comment on this post saying anything that pops into your head.  I also recommend telling me your favourite colour and favourite snack – this info may come in handy if you’re having a personalized box put together for you, right?

Second, you can enter on Facebooksimply share any one of my recipes on your own Facebook wall and then comment on the Hidden Ponies page letting me know which post you shared!  You can enter this way as many times as you like, just make sure you comment on the Facebook page every time to let me know so you get the extra entries.

The giveaway will be open for one week, and you can enter as many times as you like on Facebook, but only once via the comments here.  Can’t wait to see who wins!

Thanks so much for reading and enjoy exploring the new look!


  1. Liana says

    Love your recipes Anna! You’re my go-to site when I want to try something new or different :) Some favorite colors would be coral, and sea foam green… Haha! And snack? Dark chocolate, cheese… Mmm. Looking forward to “stalking” the new site… :)

  2. Marcelle says

    Love the new site…the recipe looks sooo good that I probably won’t make it. It falls in the category of ‘favorite foods’ and I would eat most of it myself :( I especially love your writing…and your kids :)

  3. Alanna says

    Love the new look! ! My favorite colour is purple (although teal is worthy competitor at the moment) and favourite snack would be something cheesy. :)

  4. Danielle says

    Your new blog looks great! My favorite color is purple and my favorite snacks would have to be chocolate (the darker, the better) and cinnamon buns and the like (twists, cakes…).

  5. Margaret says

    I love the colour blue. I usually eat fruit for a snack or yogurt and granola, but I can’t deny my love for chocolate and muffins and potato chips, if they are in the house. By the way, your granola recipe is amazing — I have made it probably a dozen times!

  6. MelanieD says

    Looks GREAT! Thankful for the new recipes to keep me inspired! Don’t really have a favourite colour…and anything chocolate is nice!

  7. Meagan says

    Website looks great! Favorite colour – green, favorite snack…right now I’m in love with cinnamon (english muffins, bagels, tea) and have a big craving for cinnamon buns…

  8. Renee says

    Looks great, Anna! Fresh and springy! I think I enjoy your writing as much as your recipes! You’re gifted with words and ingredients!

  9. says

    First thing – loving the sunshine outside my window. Love orange and chocolate. Recently I’ve been baking/making lots of wheat, dairy, refined-sugar, beef and pork free stuff.

    Your blog looks great!

    • says

      Ooh, you’re going to love the chocolate orange sweet rolls I have coming up soon – you’ll have to make a wheat exception ;)

  10. julie says

    I cannot count the number of chocolate chip square recipes that I have tried – every one of them DRY! If I had marshmellows in my cupboard I would be making these squares this moment! I’m a sucker for green (the exact one on your new site) and I love candy and chewy brownies!

  11. Janneke Selles says

    I like the new look… and love another chocolate recipe:) but besides all things chocolate i’m a big fan of frozen raspberry cheesecake:) YUM

  12. Keri says

    I love this blog and am often recommending it to friends. Your recipes are easy, yet delicious and very practical for families. My fav colour is probably a light blue, pink or maybe purple. And I always love to have a little cookie with my afternoon coffee :)

  13. Renae says

    Your new look is amazing. Nice teamwork :) Your profile picture even matched your new color scheme :)

    I love your blog, every recipe I’ve tried from here has been great!

  14. Andrea says

    Yay, you’re back! :) I’ve been checking almost every day to see if you were up and running yet! The new website looks great – it definitely looks very fresh. Pretty sure you know my favourite colour as you were in my wedding and you’ve seen my new laundry room. :) And as for favourite snack, anything you make without banana is always good with me! :) Love you!

  15. charlene taylor says

    LOVE your site! these bars look great! My fav color is any shade of green fav snack any nut thing

  16. Heidi says

    I love the simplicity of the new site! And the colors… Good choice! My favorite thing about your blog is reading your witty posts. There’s always something that makes me laugh out loud. :-) I still love pink, although I’m more into coral lately, and chocolate always makes me very happy -especially the sea salt stuff that Carl introduced us to… :-) Oh, and this recipe looks simply divine! Can’t wait to try it!

  17. says

    Love the new look! I was just thinking the other day that I’ve missed seeing your posts pop up in my email, so it’s nice to have you back. Chocolate is a huge hit in our house, as are cookies and muffins of almost any variety. Thanks for the chance to win…I’d love some personalized surprise mail.

  18. Rona Kuit says

    Love the new look, and love green! Also love chocolate and cheesecake ;) Sorry if I commented twice, wasn’t sure if the first one went through or not :P

    • Rona Kuit says

      oh look, it did post twice! Does this cancel me out for the giveaway? ;) And did I say I love the new look? :D

  19. Rona Kuit says

    Love the new site! Big fan of green :) Love the fact that you also feature GF recipes as my family is celiac and I’m always looking for new recipes! By the way, I love cheesecake and chocolate ;) Keep up the good work, looking forward to more amazing recipes!

  20. jolene Vanderlinde says

    All my favorite colors are showcased on your updated website! It looks fantastic and is much easier to maneuver through:) hmm… requesting an eight month pregnant mama to choose her favorite snack, not an easy feat for me to decide but I narrowed it down to four:) lemon squares, your moms chocolate chip peanut butter cookies that I’ve never managed to duplicate, your vegetable muffin recipe and lastly, cheezy bacon warm appetizer dip. Mmm yum!

  21. Keara says

    Happy Monday!! This recipe looks delicious. Just in time for all the experimenting I have been doing in the kitchen with new recipes :) Since you asked… My favourite colour is pink and I love anything chocolate or crunchy (I like to snack on something crunchy when I read lol). Hope you and your family are doing well and enjoying the few sunny days we get around here ;)

  22. Heidi says

    Your new site looks great! I enjoy trying all your recipes! I like turquoise and pink. My favourite snack is chocolate and cookies.

  23. Heidi says

    Love the new look. My favorite colors are green and purple, and favorite baked snack would be cupcakes, preferably with cream cheese frosting.

  24. Lindsay R. says

    Love the new look! Hmm… can’t say I have a favorite color as it differs depending on the context. As for favorite snack, currently too many food restrictions to have one:(

  25. Linda woelders says

    ….can’t wait to get my new kitchen up and running so I can try more of your recipes!!!…love the ‘new look’!!! (Good job,Chels! )

  26. Ashley Nicole says

    These look delicious… And I love every color, but I love purple and teal… And all things sour!

  27. Marcia says

    Loving the new website! I’m in love with turquoise these days, and of course anything chocolate I wouldn’t pass up too quickly!

  28. says

    Loving this new fresh look!
    Favorite Color is Orange (or anything bright, except pink)
    Snacks…..Tostito’s with homemade guacamole, chocolate marshmallow bars. Definitely need to try this recipe above!
    Hope your weeks turn out more “normal” soon.

  29. Lydia says

    Many of your recipes have been added to my repertoire! My favourite colours these days are teal and orange and my favourite snack is chocolate!

  30. says

    i love the colors of your site, who doesn’t love coral right? it’s such an inviting color, so congrats ! i love your recipes & this one sounds soooo good. my favorite color is purple & i love chocolate, coffee, tea & greek yogurt. thanks so much.

  31. Sharon says

    WELCOME back!!! I have missed your updates and a little look into your kitchen and your life!!! I would love to win… but I noticed that you don’t mail to Australia :) …. BUT I am coming… so you could always hold it for me!!! :) Favorite colour is Green… and food… well… I love any snack really… but….!!!!

  32. Ashley says

    Found your blog from a share for this giveaway and now have bookmarked your page. I can see myself coming back for ideas, in fact I’m writing down the things I need for this recipe right now (…chocolate cream cheese….:D). Keep up the great work! And…my fav. colour is red and my newest favourite treat is Hello Dolly Bars!

  33. Kristina says

    The new site looks so great- way easier to use! I definitely come here often for baking inspiration :)

  34. Alicia says

    Love that you’re back! I needed your site a couple times in the last little while! :)
    Fav colour is blue/turquoise
    Fav snack is anything chocolate. :)

  35. Jennifer says

    I love the new look! So fun and fresh! I have always had trouble picking my favorite colors, foods and such. I have too much to love to narrow it down to one, or at least that’s what I tell myself :). How about we go with blue (my childhood fave), and chocolate (you can’t wrong with chocolate).

  36. Tanya Togeretz says

    I never realized how often I perused your blog for recipes till it was down for a while! But the new site looks great! My favourite color is probably coral, but I couldn’t tell you what my favourite snack is. :)

  37. Jennifer says

    The new blog looks great! I am a sucker for a deep purple. I enjoy savory snacks, but also love a sweet treat now and again. One of my favourite posts from you are the Lemon coconut mini pies. I shared that one on face book. Yum!

  38. Alisa says

    Hi Anna. Your new website looks great. I love the cheerful colours. Can’t wait to start using your recipes again. My favorite color is bright blue and favorite snack is anything containing chocolate. :)

  39. Carol V says

    Your site is the first I check when needing a new recipe. Have used lots of your recipes and have a bunch pinned to try soon too.
    I like the colour purple. Two of my favourite baked snacks are nanaimo bars and brownies. Yum!

  40. Susan Christy says

    Wow – these bars sound delicious. I can’t wait to try them, which will probably be soon since I love to bake and the weather is cooling off again. Green is my favorite color, I love my dogs and have recently discovered that I love the scent of lavender. Hooked on Bath & Body Works Lavender Vanilla Pillow Mist.

  41. Kathleen says

    Your new website looks great! I love trying your recipes as well :) As for my favorite color I would have to say teal, and my favorite snack is anything to do with chocolate :)

  42. Joanna Vanderpol says

    Nice looking website, Anna! My favourite colour for the kitchen is green and yellow. My absolute favourite food are your mothers’s scones and a nut bar (butter cookie-like base with different nuts on top held together with a not too sweet glaze) at a coffee shop in Steveston. I love to bike in Steveston and the first stop is a coffee with a nut bar eaten outside on the dock!

  43. Deanna says

    So glad you’re back! Definitely my go to site for all things baking. Favourite colour – I’m so fickle, but I’d go with fuscia for today :) Favourite snack – I’m a fan of muffins and cookies, and a real sucker for a good cinnamon bun!

  44. says

    Hi Anna,
    I love the new look of your site – it looks fresh and simple. And those squares look delish! Aaaaaaand my favourite kitchen colours are blue/green/white, and my favourite snacks are your mom’s Cranberry White Chocolate scones. :)

  45. Jen Shillingford says

    Love the new look Anna! The colours are great and I can’t wait to try more of your recipes. I am about to make your lemon cupcakes with raspberry ( i think you did blackberry for yours) icing for an upcoming bday in my office, they are my fave :)

  46. Alicia Louwerse says

    Love the new look! I’m thrilled you are back…a couple times I was itching for some food inspiration :) Favourite colour: turquoise Favourite snack: I’m a total sucker for chips :S gasp!!

  47. Su VdH says

    Love the new look! My favourite color is pink, but lately I’ve been loving green.. and my favourite snack is anything with chocolate. I think we’d get along fabulously :)

  48. Meagan J. says

    Anna, I’m LOVING the freshness of the site. (Nice work Chels!) You must be over the moon excited about the new look. :)
    My fave colour is a tie between 2. Apple Green and Fushcia. (Which I’d say is rather close to your colour picks for the site!) And my favorite snack is most certainly savory foods. Crackers and cheese, any kind of dip I can dip yummy breads in, you know the sort. ;)
    Very fun giveaway, Anna! Looking forward to seeing who wins!

  49. Esther says

    I love the new look, Anna! The colours are great! I actually have two fave colours: purple and green. Favorite snack is harder…if it’s sweet, I love sugar cookies or peanut brittle. Oh, and anything lemon. Now I’m hungry! :)


  1. […] and Chocolate Coconut Fondues.  A copy of this book may need to make it’s way into the giveaway package there’s still time to get in on…go enter before you leave […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: