A Canadian Resolution: Homemade Bread (Molasses Oat Bread Recipe)

With a new year, many people are focused on new resolutions, or the revival of old resolutions that were cast to the wayside at some point in the last year or years.  This month’s Canadian Food Experience Challenge focuses on resolutions, and when it comes to food resolutions, the one I’ve made (and broken) the most often over the past couple years is to make my own bread.

The Canadian Food Experience Challenge began June 7, 2013, and as we (participants) share our collective stories through our regional food experiences, we hope to bring global clarity to our Canadian culinary identity.  Whenever I make homemade bread I feel tied to my immigrant settler roots, where there was no other way to have bread than to make it, and where people with far less leisure time than me had bread making as part of their regular routine.  Living in a country where gorgeous golden wheat fields abound, I wish good bread was a staple part of everyone’s diet, as unpopular as that is quickly becoming.  I love everything about fresh homemade bread, from crusty sourdough to soft rosemary foccacia to regular sandwich bread to sweet banana bread.

Wheat Field Free Wallpapers 28621 Design 1920x1200 Pixel

Photo from http://wakpaper.com/id158448/wheat-field-free-wallpapers-28621-1920×1200-pixel.html

This year, I’m determined to make my own bread at least 80% of the time, and I believe it’s possible because I started executing this goal a couple months ago, in the middle of a busy school semester, and no such busyness lies in my foreseeable future, so there is NO excuse this time.

Molasses Oat Sandwich Bread - healthy bread forgiving for those of us less than friendly with yeast!

What finally worked to get me making my own bread regularly?

I just simply stopped buying bread.  When you decide good bread is too expensive, and the ingredient list is too long, and you think about how fantastic fresh homemade bread looks, smells, and tastes, it’s not that hard.  Making bread takes very little hands-on time, and now that I’m home full time I know I have more than enough time.

The hardest part about the commitment was finding THE bread recipe, the one I could make all the time, that would work every time, that made every minute of work worth it.  I have a quick rise bread I make regularly because I am a creature of poor planning, but I wanted a regular go-t0 homemade sandwich bread that worked every time.  I had plenty of flat, lopsided, and dense loaves in the course of this experimentation.

I know that consistency in yeast baking is all about things that are totally my own fault, like adequate but not excessive rising time, water of the right temperature to get friendly with the yeast but not kill it, and sugar added before salt and fat so the yeast doesn’t feel inhibited, but I want a bread recipe that works for me and my approach to baking.  When I see “spoon and level flour” written like it’s some kind of rule, I laugh.  I’ve never spooned or leveled flour in my life.  I scoop it straight out of the bag with my measuring scoop, shake it a little, and dump it in.  I’m doin’ just fine.

After several failed or mediocre attempts, I eventually did what I should have done first: asked some trusted friends.  Two friends recommended the same recipe, so I knew it had to be good, and it was: THIS is now the bread recipe I use every time for our regular, everyday bread, and it is amazing.  It rises SO nice and high, the texture is perfect even when it’s toasted from the freezer, the water temperature isn’t too picky, and I can substitute more than half of the all purpose flour with whole wheat bread flour without it being any less perfect!

The Molasses & Oat Bread I’m sharing today is another bread I have found to be very forgiving of my imperfect approach to bread (and yes, life), and it’s a great option to have in the bread rotation.  It’s healthy, full of flavour, a lovely rich colour from the molasses, and perfect with things like cheese, egg salad, and jam.  It also happens to rise beautifully, and toast as well as any store bought bread.

Molasses Oat Sandwich Bread - healthy bread forgiving for those of us less than friendly with yeast!

One thing I’ve learned in bread making so far is the importance of not adding too much flour.  Just as overmixing your muffin batter will give you tough muffins, so adding too much flour will give you tough, dry bread.  This is where a stand mixer is great because you can leave it stickier and just scrape it out into your rising bowl with a spoon when the kneading is done.  If you’re doing it by hand, a great trick is to knead in a large bowl lightly coated with cooking spray and flour.  Dough sticking to a bowl is much less problematic than dough sticking to your counter and you’re less likely to add too much flour.

Baking at high elevations is a whole ‘nother story, and you’re on your own there.  Sorry.

Between this molasses oat bread, my quick rise bread, and my new go-to sandwich bread, I feel like this resolution is doable.  It’s even more doable since we aren’t actually huge bread eaters – we usually have a stash of muffins, scones, pancakes, or waffles kicking around in the freezer.  However, good bread is still a necessity in our house for under fried eggs, made into grilled cheese or grilled chocolate strawberry sandwiches, or turned into French toast. I hope my parents don’t mind homemade bread because I plan to be using their oven often while I’m there :)

Molasses Oat Sandwich Bread - healthy bread forgiving for those of us less than friendly with yeast!

The next step in the resolution is the rest of the bread products.  I’ve done homemade bagels and LOVED them, but somehow never got around to doing it again.  Same thing for homemade soft pretzels.  Then there are amazing recipes for English muffins, and those and homemade tortillas have been on my kitchen bucket list for aaages.

Which bread product does your family consume the most of, and which are you most (or least!) likely to make at home?

5.0 from 1 reviews
Molasses Oat Sandwich Bread
A healthy, forgiving homemade bread that is great fresh, freezes well, and has a great texture when toasted!
Recipe type: Bread
  • 1¼ cups boiling water
  • ¾ cup large-flake rolled oats
  • ⅓ cup fancy molasses
  • 2 tbsp butter, softened
  • 1 egg, beaten
  • 1 tsp granulated sugar
  • ½ cup warm water
  • 1 tbsp (or 1 package) active dry yeast
  • 3 cups all purpose flour (approx)
  • 1 cup whole wheat flour
  • 1½ tsp salt
  • Topping (optional):
  • 1 egg, beaten
  • 2 tbsp large-flake rolled oats
  1. In heatproof bowl, stir boiling water with rolled oats; let stand until absorbed, about 15 minutes. Stir in molasses, butter and egg.
  2. Meanwhile, in large bowl, dissolve sugar in warm water; sprinkle in yeast and let stand until frothy, about 10 minutes. Stir in oat mixture. Stir in 2-1/2 cups (625 mL) of the all-purpose flour, whole wheat flour and salt to form sticky dough.
  3. Turn out onto floured surface. Knead until smooth and elastic, adding as much of the remaining flour as necessary, about 5 minutes. Place in greased bowl, turning to grease all over. Cover with plastic wrap; let rise in warm draft-free place until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.
  4. Punch down dough; divide in half with a sharp knife. On floured surface, pat each half into 11- x 8-inch (28 x 20 cm) rectangle. Starting at narrow end, roll up into cylinder; pinch edge to seal. Fit into 2 greased 8x4"or 9x5" loaf pans. Cover with damp tea towel; let rise again in warm, draft-free place until doubled in bulk, about 1 hour.
  5. Topping: Brush loaves gently with egg mixed with a teaspoon of water; sprinkle with oats. Bake in centre of 375°F oven until loaves sound hollow when tapped on bottoms, about 36-40 minutes. Let stand 10 minutes, then run a knife around the edges and remove to wire cooling racks to cool.
Try to wait for it to cool before slicing it - cutting only part of a warm loaf often makes the rest cool unevenly, affecting the texture and making it more gummy.
Store in airtight plastic bag at room temperature for up to 4 days, or cool, slice, and freeze for longer storage.

Adapted from Canadian Living.


    • says

      I’ve never tried it, but I imagine the results wouldn’t be quite the same – molasses has a much deeper, less sweet flavour. If you don’t mind a sweeter bread, though, it should work.

  1. says

    I am just making this bread today, will let you know how it turns out. I did find however that more flour was needed when kneading due to its stickiness. It could be the flour or many other variables but one thing I know for sure is you can’t knead bread if its sticking to your fingers and palms.. I am hoping it doesn’t end up being a brick.


    • says

      It is quite a sticky dough but everything from altitude to humidity can affect the flour quantity and if I can make it I consider it a pretty forgiving bread recipe, so hopefully it still works well :)

  2. says

    Beautiful bread! I admire your perseverance and think this one is a resolution worth keeping!
    My mom has always made her own bread, though she sticks with the basic white.
    I may give this recipe a try…though it might take some tinkering because I’m at a higher altitude ;)

  3. says

    Oh this is a GORGEOUS bread, Anna! It is most definitely one that I would love to have every week! Love the texture. Now you’ve got me wanting to make my own bread regularly, too. Your loaf is so much better than anything I can buy at the store! : )

  4. says

    I totally agree with you on the ingredient list being too long on store bought bread. I stood in the bread isle the other day holding three different loaves trying to decide which was “best”. Which was to say, none of them. I should do this too. . . . Thanks for the inspiration!

  5. Loretta says

    Homemade bread is the best. My family won’t eat store bought anymore. I’ve made bread for years and still do. It is time consuming but so satisfying and knowing what ingredients are in it and no chemicals is very comforting. I also make several types of bread. One of the best cookbooks for bread I found is Peter Reinhart’s books. Your bread looks amazing.

  6. Alicia Louwerse says

    Yay! You made the sandwich bread! Isn’t it AMAZING :) :) You’ve motivated me to get off my butt and make it again, it’s been a while. I did just make raisin bread yesterday, yum!

  7. Kim says

    The recipe is printed out and waiting on the counter for you ;) I used to bake bread all the time, including raisin bread every weekend for a while, but my regular bread was too hit and miss so I gave up. Although I do still make raisin bread and cinnamon buns when I am in the mood and someone is going to be here to help us eat it. Just to warn you though, I eat way more bread when it is homemade! By the way, your Grandma Fletcher made the best bread ever…people would even buy it from her until the local bakery complained. Maybe you are following in her shoes. I’d better start buying bigger sizes :)!

  8. Irene says

    What a great resolution! I hope you can stick with it through all the shifting your family will be doing over the next couple of months. We don’t eat a lot of bread either so maybe it’s something I could commit to. hmmm…

  9. jodi says

    I’ve made english muffins before. So much fun seeing them puff up in the frying pan when you are cooking them.

  10. says

    Homemade bread really is the best – I stopped buying it at the store too so I would be forced to make it myself! This bread looks wonderful – I’ve never used molasses before in my bread – must try that!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: